Tag Archive | British

MEA Acknowledges Correspondence With Moscow On Netaji – By Mukesh Jhangiani

                                                                                                                              September 6, 2006

 

Subhas Chandra Bose as the leader of INA.

Subhas Chandra Bose (Photo: Wikipedia)

MEA Acknowledges Correspondence With Moscow On Netaji

By Mukesh Jhangiani
United News of India
New Delhi (UNI) – India’s External Affairs Ministry has acknowledged having corresponded with the Soviet and the Russian governments on the disappearance six decades ago of Netaji Subash Chandra Bose, but declined to disclose the contents.

This was reported last evening by a research group– Mission Netaji– which invoked the year old Right to Information Act to get the Ministry to share the facts in the matter.

”The requisite copies of correspondence cannot be disclosed as it involves the relations with foreign State,” was what the Mission said it was told by the Ministry’s Central Public Information Officer, E Barwa.
The Mission had inquired whether ”serious efforts were ever made from a higher level to uncover the mystery surrounding the fate of one of the greatest Indians ever.”
A legendary figure of India’s independence movement, Bose disappeared after an alleged plane crash over Taipei on August 18, 1945, which the Taiwanese authorities later said had never occurred.
The Mission sought certified copies of the entire correspondence the Ministry had with the Soviet and the Russian governments in the matter.
Declining the request, Barwa wrote to the Mission that the data ”is exempt as per the provisions of Clause 8(1) (a)&(f).”
The clauses cover ”information received in confidence from foreign Government” and ”information, disclosure of which would prejudicially affect” India’s ”security, strategic” interests.
The Mission also wrote to the Ministry, ”we understand that our Embassy in Moscow had taken up the matter with the Foreign Ministry of Russian Federation in 1992, 1995, 1997, 2001 and 2003 with dissatisfying results.”
”The request to Government of USSR and the Russian Federation were made through diplomatic channels at appropriate levels,” the Ministry replied, without elaborating.
”There was no plane crash that day– August 18, 1945– or the day before that or the day after,” former Human Resource Development Minister Murli Manohar Joshi told a conclave in New Delhi last month.

English: Gandhi and Subhas Bose, Haripura Cong...

Bose and Gandhi at 1938 Haripura Congress session (Photo: Wikipedia)

He and former Defence Minister George Fernandes were speaking on new findings that Bose ”did not die in the plane crash, as alleged” and ”the ashes in the Japanese temple are not of Netaji.”
Those conclusions by retired Supreme Court Judge Manoj Kumar Mukherjee countered the findings by two predecessors– Shah Nawaz Khan in 1956 and G D Khosla in 1970– that Bose was killed in a plane crash over Taipei, Taiwan.
Taiwanese authorities say there were no plane crashes in Taipei between 14 August and 20 September 1945.
Justice Mukherjee headed an Inquiry Commission set up by the National Democratic Alliance government in May 1999 following a Calcutta High Court order.

He gave his 672-page report in May 2006 to the United Progressive Alliance government which tabled it in Parliament declaring it has ”not agreed’ with either key finding.
The Mukherjee Commission was the first inquiry set up by a non-Congress government– the past inquiries having been ordered by Prime Ministers Jawaharlal Nehru and Indira Gandhi.
Critics have over the years charged both Khan and Khosla with having made half-hearted inquiries, intended essentially to endorse the view taken by the establishment in those years.
Speakers pointed to indications that the news of Bose’s death in August 1945 was a smokescreen for his escape to the Soviet Union to pursue the freedom struggle.
They suggested that Russia be requested formally at the highest level to open its archives to Indian scholars.
Controversy has dogged the issue over the past 61 years– with many Indians refusing to believe that Netaji was killed at the time of the alleged aircrash.
Speculation has been fuelled by the Indian authorities’ refusal to let investigators– even a retired Supreme Court Judge in this case– examine the supposedly secret files.

Published accounts say similar reluctance of Russian, British and Japanese governments to let investigators see relevant files ”strongly point to an international conspiracy.”
UNI MJ RP KN1543

Advertisements

Netaji… ‘Global Conspiracy To Suppress Truth ?’ – By Mukesh Jhangiani

                                                                                                            August 19, 2006

Netaji…’Global Conspiracy To Suppress Truth ?’

By Mukesh Jhangiani
United News of India

New Delhi (UNI) – Six decades after a legendary figure of India’s independence movement disappeared in an alleged air crash, a year-old law is being invoked to determine what really happened to Subhas Chandra Bose.

”There was no plane crash that day– August 18, 1945– or the day before that or the day after,” former Human Resource Development Minister Murli Manohar Joshi told a conclave in New Delhi last week.

Subhas Chandra Bose as the leader of INA.

Subhas Chandra Bose as the leader of INA Photo: (Wikipedia)

He and former Defence Minister George Fernandes were speaking on new findings that Bose ”did not die in the plane crash, as alleged” and ”the ashes in the Japanese temple are not of Netaji.”
Those conclusions by retired Supreme Court Judge Manoj Kumar Mukherjee countered the findings by two predecessors– Shah Nawaz Khan in 1956 and G D Khosla in 1970– that Bose was killed in a plane crash over Taipei, Taiwan.
Taiwanese authorities say there were no plane crashes in Taipei between 14 August and 20 September 1945.
Justice Mukherjee headed an Inquiry Commission set up by the National Democratic Alliance government in May 1999 following a Calcutta High Court order.
He gave his 672-page report in May 2006 to the United Progressive Alliance government which tabled it in Parliament declaring it has ”not agreed’ with either key finding.
The Mukherjee Commission was the first inquiry set up by a non-Congress government– the past inquiries having been ordered by Prime Ministers Jawaharlal Nehru and Indira Gandhi.
Critics have over the years charged both Khan and Khosla with having made half-hearted inquiries, intended essentially to endorse the view taken by the establishment in those years.
The two NDA leaders at the conclave assailed the UPA government’s stand, calling it an attempt and conspiracy to ”erase” the memory of Netaji.
Fernandes said Nehru knew that Netaji’s return would jeopardise his dynastic plans.
The event was organised by a group called Mission Netaji and All India Legal Aid Forum, an association of retired judges, lawyers and activists, to ask what then happened to Bose.
The participants included two former members of Bose’s Indian National Army– Captain Surjan Singh Yadav and V P Saini– besides researcher Purabi Roy, and some of Bose’s kin.
Speakers pointed to indications that the news of Bose’s death in August 1945 was a smokescreen for his escape to the Soviet Union to pursue the freedom struggle.
They suggested that Russia be requested formally at the highest level to open its archives to Indian scholars.
Controversy has dogged the issue over the past 61 years– with many Indians refusing to believe that Netaji was killed at the time of the alleged aircrash.
Through out the early years after independence there were unconfirmed reports and rumours about his having survived any such accident.
Speculation has been fuelled by the authorities’ refusal to let investigators– even a retired Supreme Court Judge in this case– examine the supposedly secret files.
Even attempts to confer on Bose a ”posthumous” Bharat Ratna– highest civilian honour– or bring from a Japanese monastery an urn supposed to contain his ashes– were challenged and dropped.
Some time after the Mukherjee Commission began its work there was word it was denied classified files by officials in Prime Minister Atal Behari Vajpayee’s Office and key– Home and External Affairs– ministries.

Chandra Bose with Heinrich Himmler

Bose with Heinrich Himmler (Photo: Wikipedia)

Published accounts say similar reluctance of Russian, British and Japanese governments to let investigators see relevant files ”strongly point to an international conspiracy.”
To crack the mystery, the conclave sponsors have invoked what Prime Minister Manmohan Singh calls one of his government’s key achievements– the Right to Information Act 2005.
They hope the new law would help secure access to ”basic” files which had been supplied to the first two inquiries but denied to the third inquiry.
Here is what they have requested:
— Details of action taken by the government to verify the news of Netaji’s alleged imprisonment in the erstwhile Soviet Union– allegedly reflected in an official file.
— Certified copies of the MEA’s correspondence with the Soviet and the Russian governments over Netaji’s disappearance.
— Cabinet Secretariat papers about a destroyed PMO file titled ‘Investigation into the circumstances leading to the death of Shri Subhas Chandra Bose.’
— Authenticated copies of all documents exhibited before the Shah Nawaz Committee 1956 and the GD Khosla Commission 1970-74.
A Home Ministry official has intimated the applicants that their request ”cannot be acceded to” as it concerns data disclosure of which would ”prejudicially affect” India’s ”security, strategic” interests.
The Mission has since moved the Central Information Commission which gave notice to the Home Ministry officials on August 3, asking them to respond by August 18.
Asked last night if he had heard from the MHA, Sayantan Dasgupta said, ”I have not got anything so far. We’d wait a few more days before going back to the CIC again.”
UNI MJ RP VA BS1119

Pirates Force Hostages To Call Kin: Captain’s Wife – By Mukesh Jhangiani

October 2, 2008

Pirates Force Hostages To Call Kin: Captain’s Wife*

By Mukesh Jhangiani
United News of India

New Delhi (UNI) – Somali pirates in the Aden
Gulf today forced some of 22 hostages to call home
to pressure the owners of the ship they seized 16
days ago for ransom, relatives reported tonight.

”They are asking some hostages at gun-point to speak
to their families,” Seema Goyal, wife of Captain Prabhat
Goyal, said hours after she was assured by Shipping,
Road Transport and Highways Minister T R Baalu of
”every effort” for their release.
Mrs Goyal said she learnt this from her husband who
telephoned her late in the afternoon from his ship’s bridge
and she was trying to convey it to the Shipping officials.
She said she also got telephone calls from some of the
families which had heard from sailors aboard the Chemical
tanker Stolt Valor, including Om Prakash Shukla and
Joginder Malik.
Earlier, Mrs Goyal met Mr Baalu and was assured that
”every effort” would be made to secure release of the
hostages. Also present were Shipping Secretary APVN
Sarma and Captain PVK Mohan, chairman of the National
Shipping Board.
She has also requested a meeting with United
Progressive Alliance chairperson Sonia Gandhi.
The delegation of seafarers’ relatives and friends also
included Captain Joginder Singh Gill, a member of
Company of Master Mariners, a body of experienced
nautical professionals.
She said ”we were told” by the representatives of the
ship owners and the manning company that delivery of
fresh water and medicine to the hostages was being
arranged. But Captain Goyal told her nothing had arrived
so far, she said.
On Tuesday, the 18 Indian seafarers were reported to be
running short of water and rations.
”Bring an end to the ordeal of these innocent seafarers,”
Mrs Goyal urged in a petition to Baalu.
The relatives and friends of the Indian hostages also
went on air to urge Prime Minister Manmohan Singh to
hear them for just ”a few minutes.”
Rashmi Sood, who accompanied Mrs Goyal, said she
could not get over a call she attended from a crew member
aboard the ship whose wife is in hospital.
His words were not coherent but the desperation was
most clear, she said.
The Japanese-owned tanker flying the Hong Kong flag
and manned by a crew of 22 was on way to Mumbai from
Houston in the United States when it was hijacked in the
Gulf of Aden on September 15.
The tanker is carrying phosphoric acid and lubricating
oil for end-users, including Kandla-based Indian Farmers
Fertiliser Cooperative Limited.
As many as 18 of the 22 seamen, including Captain
Goyal, are Indian, one Russian, one Bangladeshi and two
Filipinos.
The hijackers appeared to have originally demanded $6
million since then pared down to $2.5 million, Mrs Goyal
told a meeting at the Indian Society of International Law.
She said Capt Goyal and crew members have been in
touch with her from the ship’s bridge, presumably using a
satellite phone.
”These 22 sailors are living under the shadow of guns
with constant threat to their lives, and look upon the
government of India as their last hope.
She said a crew member called her two days ago and
”said they will be out of fresh water in a day or two, and
rations, in another 3-4 days.”
Under the Merchant Shipping Act 1958, the Director
General of Shipping, who licenses recruiters of Indian
seamen and officers, is also responsible for the welfare of
Indian seamen, experts say.
As many as 55 ships have been attacked off the coast of
Somalia since January and 11 were still being held for
ransom, published accounts indicate.
The International Maritime Bureau has issued an
advisory urging ships to stay 250 Nautical Miles away
from the Somali coast.
The ship was reportedly in a corridor made ”safe” by a
coalition of US, British and French forces.
An official for the recruiting agent declined to comment
on negotiations under way.
UNI MJ AM VP0040

Pirates Force Hostages To Call Kin: Captain’s Wife* – By Mukesh Jhangiani – October 2, 2008

As Hostages Await Release, Seamen Suggest ‘Role For India’ – By Mukesh Jhangiani

October 5, 2008

As Hostages Await Release, Seamen Suggest ‘Role For India’*

By Mukesh Jhangiani
United News of India

New Delhi (UNI) – Relatives and friends held a candle
light vigil last night drawing attention to the plight of 22
seafarers– 18 of them Indian– being held hostage by
Somali pirates in the Gulf of Aden over the past twenty
days.

”For the past few days,” said Seema Goyal, wife of Chemical
tanker Stolt Valor Captain Prabhat Goyal, ”they have been given
a little of rice and boiled potato.”
She was describing the conditions in which the seamen are
being kept by their captors who demanded $6 million–
subsequently pared down to $2 million– for letting the tanker
sail.
But a statement by the ship’s Japanese owners handed out at
the vigil quoted the Captain as having reported on Friday–
October 3– that ”all crew members were safe (and) there were
no injuries.”
The Japanese-owned tanker flying the Hong Kong flag and
manned by a crew of 22 was on way to Mumbai from Houston
in the United States when it was hijacked in the Gulf of Aden
on September 15.
The tanker is carrying phosphoric acid and lubricant oil for
end-users, including Kandla-based Indian Farmers Fertiliser
Cooperative Limited.’ Besides 18 Indians, the crew includes a
Russian, a Bangladeshi and two Filipinos.
Mrs Goyal and other members of the group have been
meeting Indian authorities– ministers, senior bureaucrats,
politicians– to bring home the urgency of securing the sailors’
release.
”I only want to know what is being done. What is going on,”
she said as she and other participants held the vigil near Jantar
Mantar, just off the Capital’s Parliament Street.
”These 22 sailors are living under the shadow of guns with
constant threat to their lives, and look upon the government of
India as their last hope.”
Experts say much of the initiative in the matter rests with
authorities in Hong Kong, where the ship is registered, or
Japan, where the owners belong.
One idea being pursued is Indian authorities sending a
‘neutral observer’ to the ongoing negotiations between the
Japanese owners and the hijackers, Mrs Goyal disclosed.
But wth a number of merchant naval officers taking part in
the vigil last night, the talk turned inevitably to a situation
many of them face at sea.
Although Indians constitute a bulk of seamen– more than a
half, one said– on merchant ships of various nationalities, and
the Indian government licenses recruiters on Indian soil,
recruits get little protection.
They pointed out how Americans, British and French, for
instance, have formed a coalition to work a ”safe” corridor in
the area and suggested similar effort by Indian forces.
An Indian coastal presence or participation will not only
”boost our spirits,” it would at the same time deter
trouble-makers, Captain Mukul Attri told United News of India
Special Correspondent Mukesh Jhangiani.
Under the Merchant Shipping Act 1958, the Director General
of Shipping, who licenses recruiters of Indian seamen and
officers, is also responsible for recruits’ welfare, experts say.
As many as 55 ships have been attacked off the coast of
Somalia since January and 11 were still being held for ransom,
published accounts indicate.
The International Maritime Bureau has issued an advisory
urging ships to stay 250 Nautical Miles away from the Somali
coast.
Another set of pirates who hijacked a Ukrainian freighter
carrying tanks, artillery, grenade launchers and ammunition
claimed this week they are more ”like a coast guard.”
A New York Daily quoted a spokesman for the pirates as
saying they have been misundestood by the world.
The New York Times quoted spokesman Sugule Ali as saying,
”we don’t consider ourselves sea bandits.
”We consider sea bandits those who illegally fish in our seas
and dump waste in our seas and carry weapons in our seas. We
are simply patrolling our seas. Think of us like a coast guard.”
Such remarks, experts say, stray into ”grey areas” of the 1982
Law of the Sea Convention to which India is a party.
Even the International Criminal Court appears to offer no
remedy against piracy.
On the other hand, the statement by Stolt Valor’s Japanese
owners cited expert opinion that ”Somali hijackers are now
using ‘terror tactics’.”
It also contained word that the pirates ”are using” such tactics
as having crew members exaggerate hardships on board to
cause worry to families.
The statement appeared to confirm Mrs Goyal’s account three
days ago that the Somali pirates were forcing some of 22
hostages to call home to pressure the ship owners on ransom.
It said the ”owners continue to maintain contact with the
vessel on a regular basis and are making every effort to secure
the safe release of the crew” and have kept governments posted.
It discounted ideas of a rescue action, citing an unnamed
British expert that ”for every successful rescue attempt, many
more are unsuccesssful and result in dead hostages.”
It said ”the best hope for a safe resolution to the Stolt Valor
crisis is by calm communication, rather than aggressive
military action.”
Over the past few days, Mrs Goyal and her group has met
Shipping Minister T R Baalu and External Affairs Minister of
State Anand Sharma and senior officers of the Ministries and
All India Congress Committee general secretary Rahul Gandhi.
Baalu and others have assured her that ”every effort” would
be made to secure release of the hostages.
Mrs Goyal says her husband and crew members have been in
touch with her from the ship’s bridge, presumably using a
satellite phone.
Differing accounts and interpretations contribute to relatives’
anxieties.
On Tuesday, the 18 Indian seafarers were reported to be
running short of water and rations.
She said a crew member called her and ”said they will be out
of fresh water in a day or two, and rations, in another 3-4 days.”
She said ”we were told” by the representatives of the ship
owners and the manning company that delivery of fresh water
and medicine to the hostages was being arranged. But Captain
Goyal told her nothing had arrived,” she said.
The ship owners’ statement said that ”some crew members
who had been feeling unwell… received medicine on board.”
Rashmi Sood, who attended a call from a crew member
aboard the ship whose wife is in hospital, said his words were
not coherent but the desperation was most pronounced.
”Bring an end to the ordeal of these innocent seafarers,” Mrs
Goyal urged in a petition to Baalu.
During a televised interview, the relatives and friends of the
Indian hostages urged Prime Minister Manmohan Singh to
hear them for just ”a few minutes.”
UNI MJ RP KN1352

 

 

As Hostages Await Release, Seamen Suggest ‘Role For India’* – By Mukesh Jhangiani – October 5, 2008

Prez remembers ‘Netaji’… If only

Prez remembers ‘Netaji‘ on India’s 66th Independence day. If only GoI strengthens RTI so conspirators https://docs.google.com/document/d/1EDUDX_9EuZe2_KzCqdwZ2G9f-QSr9_eT5vAJNlLFxxI/edit … are exposed.